Understanding the Differences: Orders of Protection vs. Restraining Orders vs. No Contact Orders
| Feature | Order of Protection | Restraining Order | No Contact Order |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | To protect individuals from immediate and present danger of physical harm, sexual abuse, or extreme fear of imminent harm. | To prevent parties from harassing one another or dissipating assets during a civil dispute (like a divorce). | To prohibit a criminal defendant from contacting the victim or the victim’s family. |
| Relationship Requirement | Must be a “family or household member” (spouse, former spouse, relative, child in common, or current/former dating partner). | No specific relationship required; typical in civil litigation involving divorcing spouses or business partners. | Applied to criminal defendants regardless of their relationship to the victim. |
| Who Issues It? | A judge in Circuit Court, initiated by the victim (Petitioner) filing a petition. | A judge in a civil court, initiated by a party’s attorney as part of a broader lawsuit. | A criminal court judge, requested by the State (Prosecutor) as a condition of bond or probation. |
| Enforcement | Immediate arrest by law enforcement for violations. Violations are criminal offenses. | Enforced by the judge. Violations require filing a motion for contempt of court. Police do not arrest for this. | Immediate arrest by law enforcement for violations. Results in bond revocation and new criminal charges. |
Order of Protection
- Purpose
- To protect individuals from immediate and present danger of physical harm, sexual abuse, or extreme fear of imminent harm.
- Relationship Requirement
- Must be a “family or household member” (spouse, former spouse, relative, child in common, or current/former dating partner).
- Who Issues It?
- A judge in Circuit Court, initiated by the victim (Petitioner) filing a petition.
- Enforcement
- Immediate arrest by law enforcement for violations. Violations are criminal offenses.
Restraining Order
- Purpose
- To prevent parties from harassing one another or dissipating assets during a civil dispute (like a divorce).
- Relationship Requirement
- No specific relationship required; typical in civil litigation involving divorcing spouses or business partners.
- Who Issues It?
- A judge in a civil court, initiated by a party’s attorney as part of a broader lawsuit.
- Enforcement
- Enforced by the judge. Violations require filing a motion for contempt of court. Police do not arrest for this.
No Contact Order
- Purpose
- To prohibit a criminal defendant from contacting the victim or the victim’s family.
- Relationship Requirement
- Applied to criminal defendants regardless of their relationship to the victim.
- Who Issues It?
- A criminal court judge, requested by the State (Prosecutor) as a condition of bond or probation.
- Enforcement
- Immediate arrest by law enforcement for violations. Results in bond revocation and new criminal charges.
The Rights of the Petitioner
- Stay-Away Provisions: Ordering the abuser to stay away from your home, school, workplace, or any other specific location you frequent.
- No Contact: Banning all direct and indirect communication (including texts, emails, social media, and messages sent through third parties).
- Custody and Support: Granting you temporary custody of shared minor children and ordering temporary child support or spousal support.
- Housing: Granting you exclusive care and possession of a shared residence, forcing the abuser to move out immediately.
- Pet Protection: Awarding you temporary care and custody of family pets.
How to File and the Legal Process
1. Filing the Petition
You must file a petition and an affidavit detailing the abuse at the Circuit Clerk’s office. You can file in the county where you live, where the abuse occurred, or where the abuser lives. There is no filing fee to request an Order of Protection in Arkansas, and you will not be charged for the sheriff serving the papers to the respondent.
2. The Ex Parte Hearing
Because abuse situations are urgent, the court will hold an ex parte hearing as soon as possible. This means the judge reviews your petition without the abuser present. If the judge believes you are in immediate danger, they will issue a Temporary Order of Protection, which takes effect as soon as the abuser is served by law enforcement.
3. The Final Hearing
PLEASE NOTE: If your abuser is not served before the final hearing, you are still required to be present in court on the date of your final hearing. Your matter will likely be continued until the abuser can be served with the notice of hearing. If you wish to have the Order of Protection dismissed, then it is your responsibility to come to court and request that the judge dismiss this ex-parte order.
If the Judge denies your ex-parte temporary order, you will still be given a final hearing date and can present new or more evidence then to attempt to gain an Order of Protection. Understand that if your ex-parte temporary order is denied, that is a good sign, you do not have enough evidence to get an Order of Protection but that doesn’t mean you still can’t get divorced, separate, etc.
Evidence Needed to Secure an Order
- Testimony: Your detailed, truthful account of the abuse, specifically focusing on the most recent and the most severe incidents.
- Photographic Evidence: Pictures of injuries, property damage, or torn clothing.
- Communications: Threatening texts, voicemails, emails, or social media messages.
- Official Records: Medical records from hospital visits or 911 call transcripts/police reports.
- Witnesses: Anyone who saw the abuse occur or witnessed the immediate aftermath.
What is NOT Evidence to Secure an Order
- Someone calling your bad names or using foul language towards you.
- Someone talking bad about you on social media.
- Your new boyfriend/girlfriend being the target of the abuser’s actions (If another adult is being threatened or has been physically assaulted, they will have to seek legal options.) You can only seek an Order of Protection for yourself and/or your children, not another adult.
- The abuser breaking or destroying your property
- The abuser driving up and down the street in front of your house (provided it is a public road). If they are all private property, then law enforcement should be contacted to seek a trespassing notice.
Consequences for the Respondent (Someone is seeking an Order of Protection against You): Rights Lost
- Loss of Firearm Rights: Under federal law (and often state restrictions), you cannot purchase, own, or possess a firearm or ammunition while a qualifying domestic Order of Protection is active.
- Loss of Housing: You can be evicted from your own home with no notice if you share the residence with the Petitioner.
- Custody Restrictions: You may lose access to your children, or be forced into highly restrictive, supervised visitation.
- Background Checks: The order is entered into the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) database. It will show up on background checks, potentially impacting employment, housing, and professional licenses.
- Criminal Liability: Even a minor, non-violent violation of the order (like sending a text message) is a Class A Misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in jail. Repeat violations or violations involving weapons escalate to felony charges.
The Importance of a Seasoned Attorney
For the Petitioner: A seasoned attorney will help you build a compelling case, ensure your petition is procedurally flawless, gather the right evidence, and shield you from aggressive cross-examination by the abuser’s lawyer. They ensure your voice is heard clearly and legally.
For the Respondent: False or exaggerated allegations do happen, often strategically deployed during divorce or custody battles. An experienced defense attorney can challenge the credibility of the claims, expose ulterior motives, object to inadmissible evidence, and protect your constitutional right to bear arms and parent your children. If you are served with an order, you need a lawyer immediately to prevent a temporary ex parte order from becoming a decade-long restriction.
Get Professional Legal Help
To discuss your situation with experienced legal professionals who understand Arkansas family and civil law, reach out to CLM Law Firm.
Note: This blog is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. If you are facing criminal charges, please consult with a licensed attorney regarding the specifics of your case.